Monster Cookie Peanut Butter brings the cozy charm of a fresh-baked cookie into every spoonful. This thick, creamy-meets-chunky spread starts with dry roasted peanuts and hearty oats, lightly sweetened with honey and finished with a touch of sea salt, vanilla, and cinnamon. Softly blended dark chocolate adds a rich, fudgy depth that ties everything together. Each jar is topped with a sprinkle of colorful Unreal M&Ms for that true monster-cookie feel — playful, nostalgic, and irresistibly eye-catching. Perfect for spreading, dipping, or devouring straight from the jar. (This flavor is dairy free!)
 
Crafted with wholesome ingredients, this is a treat you can feel good about. Packed with plant-based protein, heart-healthy fats, and fiber, it provides lasting energy without refined sugars or additives.
 
What is a Specialty Flavor?
My Nutterly Delicious Specialty Flavors are small-batch creations crafted with imagination and care. These unique nut butters go beyond the core lineup, featuring specialty ingredients, limited-edition blends, seasonal inspiration, and extra time and attention in every batch. From holiday-inspired flavors to one-of-a-kind ingredient combinations, these jars are available only for a limited time—once they're gone, they may not return! Whether it's a cozy winter spice or a fresh summer twist, the Specialty Flavors are your chance to taste something unexpected, indulgent, and truly special.